A federal judge in Massachusetts has ruled against the Trump administration’s policy of deporting individuals to countries where they have no prior connection, declaring it illegal. Judge Brian Murphy emphasized that the government cannot deport people without notice, especially to countries where they might face persecution or torture. The case began when eight migrants, intended for South Sudan, were mistakenly rerouted to Djibouti, neither of which were listed on their deportation orders. Immigration advocates sued, seeking their return to the U.S. for due process. Murphy insisted that individuals must be deported to the countries specified on their removal orders, or at least be given the chance to challenge their removals.
Previously, the Supreme Court temporarily paused Judge Murphy’s order, allowing the government to proceed with deportations to third countries without providing adequate notice. Despite this, Murphy’s recent ruling mandates that meaningful notice must be given to allow time for legal challenges. The Trump administration contended their actions, claiming compliance with the law and safety assurances from South Sudan, but Murphy paused his ruling for 15 days to permit an appeal. His decision impacts those facing removal to third countries not listed on their deportation orders after February 2025.